Best Online Comics Criticism: Kibbitzing

Posted by on January 20th, 2011 at 7:45 AM

I wasn’t involved in the selection process for the best online comics criticism this year…but at HU I’ve gone ahead and written about two of my favorite pieces of criticism from last year anyway. They’re by Shaenon Garrity (on Cathy) and Matt Seneca (on Rob Liefield).

Be Sociable, Share!

Tags: ,

5 Responses to “Best Online Comics Criticism: Kibbitzing”

  1. BCMoore says:

    Oh, good. I was wondering when bloggers would get around to skewering Rob Liefeld and Cathy.

  2. Noah Berlatsky says:

    Ummm…they’re both positive pieces. Shaenon likes Cathy (more or less); Matt likes Rob Liefield (a lot).

  3. BCMoore says:

    Forgive my reaction, but the condescension is dripping off the monitor.

  4. Noah Berlatsky says:

    Neither of the pieces is condescending in the least. Particularly if you’re a Liefield fan, it seems like you’d appreciate Matt’s essay….

  5. Forgive my reaction, but the condescension is dripping off the monitor.

    No it’s not, and you don’t believe that it is.